The School We Want

by Alberto Borghi

Interview with Mariangela Bastico, Vice Minister of Public Instruction and member of the Istituto F. Cavazza's Honorary Committee, on the present and future of the Italian school system.


Yesterday's and today's school. What are the most recent innovations and what future steps will be taken?
Coherently with the Government's program, we have worked with the “screwdriver method" on the Moratti laws, taking it apart piece by piece. This work concerned either the parts that are not shared or those less applied: the tutor, the portfolio and the optional subjects, the experimentation on secondary school. The most considerable part of our work was the structure designed to define and approve the new normative posts on which to base the school we want: a public school of quality which leaves no one behind, meaning that it accompanies all students - all and not one less - to the diploma or a professional qualification. With the Financial Act of 2007 it became a law to increase the obligation for instruction to 16 years old and the consequencial increase of the age to enter the labour market. Also because of the Financial Act, the national system includes the education of adults and the IFTS (Higher Instruction and Technical Training) with their resulting stabilization and allocation of resources. The instruction no longer ends, therefore, as occurred with Law 53, at 19 years of age, but continues with avenues after the diploma, even with alternatives to university, and with training throughout life, coherently with European directions. With the decree on deregulations, we have reintroduced technical and professional institutions, bringing back to unity the national system for higher instruction. This way, we wanted to increase the value of technical and professional instruction, particulary weak today following the decisions that were made on secondary education in Law 53. This choice is subsequently reinforced by the fact that we had planned, in each province, the institution of polytechnical professional cooperative facilities created to support the economic and productive development of the area. The choice to reconstruct “little by little” the school system is based on the firm belief that true change is created through the work of the independent schools and an enhanced value of the teachers' role. I know well that school autonomy is still at an early stage (it came into effect in 2000) and in recent years it has been strongly hampered and held back by the centre-right government. Instead, we want to enhance its status, and for this we have introduced standards of special importance, such as the innovation in funding modes to schools and the institution of the National Agency for the Development of Independence.
A small gesture for the reform of the State exam which, with the collaboration of the parliament majority, we have approved very rapidly because it was necessary to immediately give back authoritativeness and credibility to it,

as a guarantee for the legal and fundamental value of the degree received and for the protection of the commitment of students, teachers and families. Concerning the next steps, we are working on the new national directions, beginning from the first cycle, changing them to those approved by Moratti, and, together, on the guidelines for the mandatory period of two years. Two commissions are working on these objectives and they are almost done elaborating documents on which we intend to open a wide discussion with schools, as well as professional and cultural organizations.

What rights and aids are guaranteed by the law for students with disabilities?
Law 104 guarantees students with disabilities their integration in school. I think this is a very important principle which is still not guaranteed in many European countries. This same law provides for the support of specialized teachers. The Financial Act 2007 sets new conditions concerning the allocation of specialized teachers to the independent schools: no longer based on the ratio of one teacher for 138 students, but on the basis of the recognized disability. I am convinced that this new modality of assigning specialized teachers, overcoming the very strict previous constraints, will allow a better integration of the students.

Can the system of instruction and higher technical training offer effective answers to the employment needs of people with disabilities?
I have the firm belief that it is so, particularly thanks to the development of the technical and professional areas of instruction, that we want to bring forward and that will facilitate without a doubt the workplace integration of young people.

All of them, not one less: what instruments are offered by the disposition to convert the slogan into reality? 
A better link between the knowledge an the know-how means that the school becomes truly inclusive, and no one is left behind. In school there have to be ways of teaching not only theoretical aspects but also practical elements. Only in making a difference in the training and teaching possibilities, creating personalized avenues, respecting the various ways there are to learn and the aptitudes of each student, will we arrive at the "not one less".

What is the meaning of school independence?
The real meaning of school independence stems from a legal expression of a community of students who learn, of teachers, parents, relations with local agencies and with economic, social and cultural organizations in the territory; not like an isolated subject or in competition. Therefore, no to the school as a business, yes to the school as a community.

Picture of Mariangela Bastico, Vice Minister of Public Instruction


We have proposed to implement this concept through Il Capitolone (The Big Chapter) which contains, in only two chapters of budget, all the financial transfers from the State to the schools for their operation, except payment for personnel. The funds, more than 2 billion 800 million Euro, are transferred directly to schools on the basis of predetermined criteria, entrusting in them managerial autonomy, definition of priorities and responsabilities. Moreover, I believe that the essential value of school autonomy is in the elaboration of the instruction offer, in the research and educational experimentation, and the dissemination of innovations. To reach these objectives, schools need technical, cultural, and pedagogical support. This is why the Agency was established, whose modality will be defined eventually with a set of rules.

Picture - Reading a Braille document

Picture of students in class in elementary school