All that Glitters is not Gold
By Federico
Bartolomei
Different
treatment by the media for olympic athletes.
The paraolympics are games in
which participate disabled athletes animated by the same spirit and the same
enthusiasm as the abled-bodies.
For obvious reasons, it is not conceivable
to imagine direct challenges between disabled and non-disabled athletes, but
some results achieved, in different cases, are not so far from the records
attained by the super athletes we are used to see on television. Besides, we
have all seen by now the passionate and enjoyable sporting events with disabled
athletes winning against titled champions obligated to confront each other, of
course, on equal terms.
A
pioneer in introducing sporting activities in the life of persons with
disabilities was Sir Ludwig Guttmann, neurosurgeon at the hospital of Stoke
Mandeville, near London. He first proposed training programs to young soldiers
from the British armed forces, who had bone marrow injuries, with the
intention of avoiding secondary pathologies to the disability.
Dr.
Guttman's initiative was very well received and on July 28, 1948 the first games
took place in Stoke Mandeville for disabled athletes. The first event of olympic
status, however, took place in 1960, immediately after the 17th Olympics in
Rome.
Today, the paraolympics are just like the Olympic Games and the
International Olympic Committee has decided that they must take place in the
same country as the Olympic Games.
Nelson Bova is a journalist by now very
well known in the social environment. For four years now, he has been
writing the weekly column Abilhandicap concerning disability for Rai's Emilia
Romagna office. On the occasion of the Olympic Games of Athens 2004, he was
our correspondent to the paraolympics.
"This fantastic experience" explains
Nelson "has confirmed to me how responsive human beings are facing
the hardships of life." Even if he has been in the field for years, the
challenges and successes of disabled people continue to interest and astonish
him. He does not lose an occasion to describe them to us with the sense of
detail of the columnist and the sensibility of a man who has been beyond the
common places where often our imagination no longer works.
"Attending
swimming races: there are no prosthesis that can compensate, even visually, your
handicap. Nude, you are there to confront the challenge. Watching a swimming
competition, I thought right away how Athens was a wonderful place, full of
meaning and probably the best adapted city to host the paraolympics (I know that
there should be no letter 'o' there and that I should write
'paralympics' but, I'm sorry, I write it anyway because I refuse to accept the
reasons behind this, that the term 'olympics', like the graphical olympic
symbol, has not been authorized by the rights owners for this event). Athens,
with its statues, represents ancient Greece and is the testimony of a history
based on thousands of years of challenges, conquests, progress, and growth. Time
has taken away the hands of the statues or whole arms, or even legs, but they
are still here to this day. They have seen, and even fought wars, overcame
devastations. They have been faced with the obtuse mind of the human being, but
they are still here to tell us that with
their perseverance they have overcome, beyond expectations, all offences of
time.
These nude swimmers, physically incomplete, on the side of the pool,
ready to confront the umpteenth challenge, have immediately brought to mind
images of Greek statues. Two of them did not have three limbs out of four.
But not only did they swim fast, once arrived at the winning post - the side of
the pool that those without arms have to touch with their head - they stayed in
the water talking and making jokes with their trainer, moving like a propeller
the only leg or arm.
Then on to an interview in the mixed zone with
countrymen journalists, probably their only moment under the spotlight in the
last 4 years."
Nelson Bova speaks to us about sporting challenges under the
spotlight, just when in Italy there is a growing polemic over the little
attention given to the event by television and over the different coverage on
olympic and paraolympic athletes.
"There is a lot to say about the matter
concerning the paraolympics and the Italian media" he explains "I will only give
this symbolic exemple: while I was in Athens, various friends called me,
strangers to my work and the olympic environment. I told them I was in Athens
for the paraolympics and many answered me: aren't the olympics over in August?
My hotel hosted the Dutch tv staff which had set up its studio for their daily
broadcasting near the pool on the last floor. Seeing every day these people
dressed in orange, I thought to call an Italian friend, also not from my
professional environment, who lives in Amsterdam. I only told him I was in
Athens, and he immediately asked: You're there for the paraolympics? Here, every
newspaper is talking about it."
In Italy, the major news was
probably about the remarkable difference in economic compensation between
the gold olympic medal winner and the gold paraolympic medal winner. "Yes,
this was one of the many arguments discussed in meetings and press conferences
during the competitions, but certainly not the only one. If more money is to be
given, it is best to invest it in preparing athletes and providing them
with facilities, in light of the game's disappointing results: 19 medals.
Only a few years ago, we were able to win over 50 of them. Analyzing the
context, however, everyone agreed that the other athletes had improved, not that
ours had gotten worse.
It can be said, though, that this time there was
more media coverage, at the international level, then ever before at the
the Paraolympics. Time has passed, fortunately, where televisions explained
their refusal to broadcast the event based on the supposedly shocking images and
the feeling of pity aroused by images of the athletes."
There olympic
experience also created strong impressions in a year full of world events which
have little to do with sports and pleasure.
"I have hands-on experience of
the limitations to freedom brought on by fear of terrorism. Since
Seoul, in 1988, olympics and paraolympics use the same infrastructures. The
excellent organization put together for the August event by Greece
was exactly the same for the paraolympics, in terms of environments and
occupied areas. Even the security systems stayed the same, with continuous
controls with the metal detector, very long mandatory distances and drastic
limited access to some areas. Sometimes it happened that to go from one stadium
to another in the same complex or even within the same stadium, a few meters as
the crow flies became never-ending walks, with heavy equipment to carry under
the sun or through nondescript corridors. Long distances justified by the
overcrowded olympic event, but a bit irritating, however, for the few spectators
at the paraolympics." Maybe the paraolympics are penalized even for the fact
that they do not occur at the same time as the olympics. "Symbolically yes, I
think. But, we have to take into consideration other aspects which are not
secondary at all. To have competitions at the same time would require a longer
stay (and that is certainly not feasable because of the few
resources available to our disabled athletes), and if
competitions were to alternate, enormous investments in infrastructures
would be required in order to host all athletes at the same time. But the most
negative result of this choice would be the complete absence of media attention
at the paraolympics, obscured by the prowess of the abled-body athletes. An
unforgivable error. If we want to give some value to symbolic gestures, let's
leave things as they are, but let's light up the olympic flame just once at the
beginning of the olympics and extinguish it just once at the end of the
paraolympics. Because, in the end, the event is unique and it does not matter
whether the torchbearer is abled or disabled. What matters is that he or she is
an athlete.
And let's not repeat the error of our Chief of State who has
welcomed at the Quirinale the olympic athletes on the last day of the
paraolympics.
But these are all personal views elaborated upon my return in
Italy. During the competitions, I worked a lot, but most of all I had fun. It
happens often to me to use the word fun when I am referring to experiences
humanly enriching."